Join for FREE | Take the Tour Lost Password?
[x]

deviantART

 
©2007-2009 =Talescaper
:icontalescaper:

Artist's Comments

This photo participated in the Dutch amateur art-contest for Het Vierkante Ei

Model: =lifemachine
Camera: Praktica Super TL2
Film: Fuji S-200 Colour

Critiques


:iconnycterent:
Oh! =lifemachine. Ha, just met 'em yesterday -- small world. That bit of serendipitous chance aside, the photograph!

Here's what the I see - a sort of meshing of the natural world and the human world as the flesh and face is part of the tree and moss and greenery. The blurred green twig on the right-most side seems almost like a green tattoo (and that's what I thought it was on the small thumb!). This kind of great confusion of what's "human" and what's separate and nature creates a great feel here. One can't see the lips so the expression isn't easy to define. There are no smile wrinkles around the visible eye, but the eye is narrowed. I can't decide if the model is smiling very slightly (a sort of Mona Lisa smile) or simply staring through hooded eyes (because of tiredness or bright light). That also adds to that ambiguity that I mentioned earlier. The viewer isn't certain whether life-as-a-garden is a good and happy thing, or neutral, or negative.

An argument can be made for it being a negative, as some of the image is slightly grotesque -- the protruding green-moss instead of the eye, for example, is somewhat disturbing (and reminded me a lot of how cyborgs are depicted in movies). This is something to consider if the intention was for there to be an elegant transition from flesh to nature. That moss sticks out, rather than merges. A smaller size might have seemed more natural, though, the current effect isn't necessarily bad - just not holistic. (Just out of curiosity, did you take this with the model lying down and then flip it?) All depends on what overall impression you were going for with this.

Now more technical things. I did a brief scan of the comments on the first page, and I noticed quite a few people saying they like the focus and its sharpness. I'm going to go against the flow and say that the focus didn't work for me. Barring the softness of the bottom right where the leaves seem part of the cheek, the shot felt out-of-focus for me and after the first look, my eyes kept trying to look at the eye and the hair and the details. They were softened and made me want to clean my glasses.

I don't know about most people, but in a close up portrait shot, the eyes/eye may not be the first thing I look at, but my gaze travels to it inevitably. Here, the softness of the eye pushes me away and hurts my overall impression. I realize that a full sharpen filter won't do any good, but perhaps a sharpen brush on the eye and a few other focus points might make the image more compelling? I sincerely feel that it would add to the photograph.

Speaking of the eye, have you played around with the idea of strengthening the color of the eye. Obviously anything extreme will make the natural-ness feel of the image seem contrived, so I'm not suggesting the model's eyes be poison green. However, a slight tinge of color might add a holistic sense of the human being an integral part of nature rather than just slowly being consumed by it (a possible interpretation). All depends on intended direction, really.

My last critique/suggestion would be about the border. I'd remove it. I found that borders tend to strengthen nature shots and shots with lines and geometry. However, with portrait shots, they often stifle. Here, the border is a distraction, in my opinion, and without it, the image has more openness and seems more genuine. I'd remove it.

So yes, a few thoughts. Thank you for sharing, for your critique, and good luck with your art! :heart:
The Artist thought this was FAIR
3 out of 3 deviants thought this was fair.

Thank you for your Critique

You are not logged in.

Comments


love 1 1 joy 0 0 wow 1 1 mad 0 0 sad 0 0 fear 0 0 neutral 0 0
:iconlovercraft:
great photo :clap:

--
this is my new gallery [link]
I'll be working on there...
:iconkasia88:
i like that photh...the moss eye looks just sweet XD

--
"It is not the appearance that defines a true monster, but the actions on one's account." - Azuryt
Quote is (c) to me K. Zalecka
:iconninika90:
Oooh lovely <3

--
Thousands of candles can be lighted from a single candle, and the life of the candle will not be shortened. Happiness never decreases by being shared.
:icongregowich:
i like it more than 'she wants to be a garden' to tell the truth, i think it's one of your best so far. the neutral face is perfect for the shot and the positioning of the plants works nicely, i expect it was intentional... and the vertical change of the composition (i suppose, unless you glued the plants on the poor model :P) is a nice touch.

Usually with your work i feel like you dwell too much in the 'thought' part, and not enough in the application, but this time it seems like it was balanced real well, hence the beautiful piece.
keep up the good work!

--
.imagine.
:iconcircleoflight:
This is beautiful and intriguing. I like how the model has become part of the earth.

--
heaven isn't some place that we go to when we die
It's that split second in life where you actually feel alive

- Eyedea & Abilities
:icontalescaper:
Thanks :D It was a really fun shot to do, especially with finding arranging all the plants and bits :D Everything's fresh from the ground, so to say.

And yeah, I seem to be more interested in the thought behind the photo then the photo itself... I just love telling a story and will do so any way I can :D

--
Supporting and informing deviants near you
--
Sine Somnis, Sumus Nemo.
:iconmirrortea:
This turned out humongously awesome. The colors and focus is excellent. As is the fact that it looks like she's wearing a crown of the forest. But even if she would have been some sort of an emperor, she doesnt seem quite at ease with it. At least that's the feeling I get from it, with the branch covering her mouth - almost telling her to rule but with silence, as if the forest itself only uses her and tells her what to do.

The forest do, after all, rule itself.

--
Rats shrivel up and die if they dont, like, get to hang out with other rats ...
:icontalescaper:
Hmmm so the Monarch of the Forest is powerless? Perhaps... Us humans have a hard time understanding that in the parliament of nature, we have only a small vote.

--
Supporting and informing deviants near you
--
Sine Somnis, Sumus Nemo.
:iconxenonia:
wonderful....<3 beautiful...ah love it:)

--
♥ Carina Renée

Details

August 5, 2007
81.0 KB
81.0 KB
533×800

Statistics

97
337 [who?]
4,197 (1 today)
0 (0 today)

Site Map